Review - Coal Black Horse

Coal Black Horse
By Robert Olmstead
200 pages

Description via Goodreads

His belly swooped low and dashed at his pelvis where it fluttered. This night was war. The falling rain was war. The clipped moon was war. The earth where they stood and the sky they stood under was war (103)

Despite the title, the story is not about a coal, black horse. It’s about a journey, a mini epic if you will. The journey of Robey Childs, a youth of fourteen, sent on an almost impossible mission to seek out his father on the battlefields during the peak of the Civil War. A coal, black horse leads him through the battle-torn North and South, but again it’s not about the horse, it’s about Robey figuring out the equation of war and how it will shape him into a man. 

A lot happens in this mini epic…mostly horrific things and death. It’s through these close encounters with death that Robey is able to internalize lessons of survival.

Lessons learned in a time of war…
…be angry.
…do not despair.
…trust no one.
…bad things will happen and you will do bad things.
…be unknown and unseen.
…the dead will kill you.
…you will gain immunity to the smell of death.
…everyone believes in the same mistake.
…people should be born twice.
…belief in God is finished.
…war is the nature of man.
…let the past go.
…you will become one of many failed humans.            

I’m sure there were more lessons throughout the book, but these were the ones I remembered. Some are potentially universal…or at least relevant in the war and conflict of today and possibly of the future.
Strewn over the few hundred acres was everything a man carried inside and out. There were enough limbs and organs, heads and hands, ribs and feet to stitch together body after body and were only in need of thread and needle and a celestial seamstress (116)
The language in this book is beautiful, there is powerful, vivid imagery and the subject matter is grisly, bleak and dark. If you don't like that combination, then this book might not be for you...I thought it was interesting that although the story is set in the Civil War, the issue of slavery is lightly brushed upon…not a complaint just an observation. My least favorite part of the book was Rachel. Not because she was a poorly developed character, but simply because I didn’t like her. If I were Robey I couldn’t justify her company. She was a hazard. My favorite part was the end, even though the last few chapters made me sad. Robey did what he had to do. Forever changed by war and no longer a boy, the son becomes the father.

Coal Black Horse 
Five stars.



  1. I haven't read many books set during the Civil War, even despite my interest in historical fiction. You've definitely got me curious about this book. Thanks for the great review and recommendation!

  2. I haven't either...I can probably count on one hand the number of books I've read that are set during the Civil War. Half would be slave narratives.

    Thanks for reading my review!